In February 2006 the
Danish Cattle Federation initiated a national voluntary control
programme "Operation Paratuberculosis"
("Operation PTB"). The programme focuses on closing
transmission routes, because it has been demonstrated to be
essential for the control of paratuberculosis in cattle herds.
However, closing transmission routes is also difficult to practice,
because persistence and much extra labour is needed. This amount of
labour is reduced in "Operation PTB" which implies
diagnostics of all cows 3-4 times per year by milk-ELISA, and
- in cooperation with the herd health advisor - a
contingency plan for changes in management and housing systems is
made in order to reduce transmission of PTB. Transmission routes
between calves and all cows being diagnosed as infectious
should be broken effectively, and the most infectious cows culled
before the next calving. The improvement of management is thus
focused only on cows having been diagnosed as infectious instead of
on the whole herd. Thereby the labour and time needed for improving
management are reduced considerably.
The expected long-term
effects of this strategy compared to alternative strategies were
evaluated by simulation studies with the herd-simulation model
PTB-Simherd. Scenarios were simulated in a herd with 200 cows (500
replications), an initial herd prevalence of 25% and an otherwise
typical Danish herd management.
The simulated results of
following "Operation PTB" were a reduction of
prevalence from 25% to 5% after 5 years and less than 1% after 8
years, which makes this strategy just as effective in reducing
prevalence as if management had been optimized for all cows
in the herd. If no action was taken to control PTB, the prevalence
would increase to 75% after 10 years. If transmission routes were
not broken by improving management, but infectious cows were still
culled within the next calving, the prevalence continued to
increase to 26-39% depending on how quickly the infectious cows
were culled after having the diagnosis. The economy of
"operation PTB" compared to the economy of optimizing
the management of all cows (which implies more labour hours,
but no costs for tests) depends directly on the hourly rate and the
time spent on optimizing management. If the extra workload per
calving is assumed to be 1 hour, "Operation PTB" is the
economically most attractive option in Denmark whenever the hourly
rate exceeds 7 € (9 $).