Paratuberculosis has been suspected to have a genetic component and
estimations of heritability of about 0.15 have been reported.
Caspase recruitment domain 15 (CARD15/NOD2) is a gene codifying for
a cytosolic protein implicated in bacterial recognition by cells
involved in innate immunity. This protein modifies inflammatory
responses to bacterial triggers through activation of the nuclear
factor-kB. Crohn's disease (CD) is an idiopathic inflammatory
bowel disease in humans similar in many features to bovine
paratuberculosis and involves an aberrant mucosal immune response
in genetically susceptible individuals. The association between
mutations in the CARD15/NOD2 gene and increased risk of CD has been
described. The objective of this candidate gene case-control study
was to characterize the distribution of two polymorphisms in the
bovine CARD15/NOD2 gene and test their association with
paratuberculosis infection in Florida dairy and beef cattle. The
study population consisted of 432 adult cows composed of Holstein,
Jersey and Brahman-Angus crosses distributed in four herds. The
infection status for cases and controls was determined using five
diagnostic tests (serum ELISA, milk/blood/fecal nested PCR, and
fecal culture). Parallel interpretation of the results was used to
compensate for limitations in sensitivity of available diagnostic
tools. Two previously reported single nucleotide polymorphisms
(SNP1; C733R and SNP2; Q1007L) in the bovine CARD15/NOD2 gene,
responsible for two amino acid substitutions, were established for
the study population by the TaqMan® genotyping
assay. The statistical analysis was based on Chi-square and
Fisher's Exact Test and different models were proposed for
the logistic regression analysis. It was our central hypothesis
that a combination of particular alleles in our candidate gene
would be present in higher frequency in controls compared to cases,
suggesting a role in resistance to infection. The resulting ratio
of cases to controls was 1:2.5. Frequencies for the major allele in
SNP1 and SNP2 two were 0.957 and 0.543, respectively. The
population was in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium for SNP2 but not for
SNP1. Values for coefficient of linkage disequilibrium (LD), the
normalized LD, and the correlation between the two SNPs were
-0.027, 1.0, and -0.23. Chi square test indicated that SNP1 and
SNP2 are in linkage disequilibrium. The statistical analysis
resulted in significant differences in allelic frequencies between
cases and controls for SNP1 (p<0.001) indicating a significant
association between infection and mutant allele. In the analysis of
genotypes a significant association was found between SNP1 and
infection status (P<0.0001). A significant association between
allele combinations and infection status was found (P<0.0001)
when both SNPs were considered in the genotype. The low
representation of the variant allele for SNP1 in Holstein and
Jersey breeds raises the prospect of a potential confounding role
of breed for its connection with infection. However, a significant
association between SNP1 and infection was confirmed when tested
within the Brahman-Angus sub-population (P=0.02). Preliminary
results suggest a role for CARD15/NOD2 gene in the susceptibility
of cattle to paratuberculosis infection. Amino acid substitution
C733R (SNP1) appears to be associated to paratuberculosis infection
in Florida cattle. These results could be the basis for further
research to create a rapid method to select for more resistant
individuals, genetically contributing to the control of Johne's
disease.